Best Pool Cleaners in 2017 – Reviews & Top Picks

Tired of cleaning your pool manually with a vacuum, skimmer, or brush? Then it’s time, high time for you to get a pool cleaner. These are cleaners that can be left behind while you do your chores, take a shower, or whatever you like. They are made to collect debris and sediment in a swimming pool with minimal human involvement.

Without pool cleaners, cleaning the pool will be time-consuming and exhausting, especially during summer. It’s such a waste to spend time cleaning the pool instead of actually swimming in it. Besides, you’ll need other special equipment to clean manually, and there’s a tendency that you won’t be able to clean the pool completely. Aside from giving you more time to enjoy, you will also save money because you don’t have to hire a professional pool cleaner to do the job.

There are so many choices on the market and they can be overwhelming. Choosing may confuse you but with this guide you’ll be able to come up with a decision. You’ll also learn about the three types of pool vacuums on the market, so you can determine what’s best for your pool.


Best Robotic Pool Cleaners

ModelWeightWarrantyUser RatingPrice
Dolphin Nautilus Plus
Dolphin 99996403-PC Dolphin Nautilus Plus
19 lbs.2 Years4.7/5$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon
Dolphin Triton
Dolphin Trition
48 lbs.2 Years4.2/5$$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon

#1 Dolphin Nautilus Plus

Dolphin Nautilus PlusThis lightweight, easy-to-use, efficient pool cleaner absorbs the debris and dirt from in-ground pools. It doesn’t just keep your water clean and safe, it even polishes the surface of the pool with its firm brushes. Unlike other pool cleaners, this features a straight base with rotating brushes that move it while others have large wheels on their sides.

It also features a 60-feet power cable with an advanced sniveling mechanism. In short, it won’t get tangled while working. Plus, its intelligent self-programmed mapping system scans the shape of your pool and creates a cleaning route that allows it to thoroughly clean your entire pool. It also highlights a programmable timer that controls for how long it works before it automatically shuts off. This is a practical and convenient feature to help you save energy.

The Dolphin Nautilus Plus is very easy to use because it does not need any installation. It comes fully assembled. Just plug it in and it will be all set to work. Because of these features, it is the bestseller on Amazon, the best pool cleaner for the money, and the best in-ground pool cleaner on the market.
For all that, this cleaner also has a drawback. It stops when the filter cartridge is full and it won’t start again until the filter is removed and cleaned and the motor has been restarted.


#2 Dolphin Triton

Dolphin TritonIf you need a convenient, efficient, high-quality robotic in-ground pool cleaner, then you need a Dolphin Triton. This pool cleaner is perfect for different types of pool, regardless of the materials used. It scrubs, vacuums, and filters at the same time. With a suction rate of about 4,233 gallons per hour unit, who would look for another model? In just under an hour, it will give you a dirt-free and debris-free pool.

In addition, the Triton is so compact that climbing up the walls of your pool and precisely cleaning your pool from sand and small particles are as easy as pie. It even comes with a caddy that is designed for easy storage. With this pool cleaner, you’ll also get a robotic scanning technology that will allow you to save energy and money in the long run. Saving is achievable because it automatically scans the size of your pool and decides on how it can clean your pool efficiently and quickly.

You won’t have trouble with the 60-feet cable as well. Even if it’s long, it’s swiveled to avoid tangling. No installation is required, too. Just plug it in, place it in your pool, and press the start button.

However, the only disadvantage is its lack of innovative features. The features aren’t enough to make it worth its price. That, of course, is from some of the customers only.


Best Suction Pool Cleaners

ModelWeightWarrantyUser RatingPrice
Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000020
Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000020
19 lbs.2 Years4.4/5$$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon
Hayward PHS21CST Aquanaut
Hayward PHS21CST Aquanaut 200
16 lbs.2 Years4.2/5$$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon
BARACUDA G3 W03000 Advanced
BARACUDA G3 W03000 Advanced_100x
19 lbs.1 Year4.1/5$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon

#1 Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000020

Hayward Poolvergnuegen 896584000020Commonly known as “The Pool Cleaner”, this Hayward product features a four-wheel drive that cleans large and deep pools up to 20’ x 40’. Other highlights include its patented self-adjusting turbine vanes, patented tire treads, patented adjustable roller skirt, and multiple pre-programmed internal steering sequences.

What’s great about its patented self-adjusting turbine is it allows maximum power at any flow and provides passage of large debris through the cleaner. The tire treads are great for enhanced wall climbing, obstacle management, and maximized pool coverage; while the roller skirt optimizes suction on surfaces that are uneven.

Its steering system causes the left wheel to periodically reverse, allowing the Pool Cleaner to turn and move in another direction. You won’t need to supervise this cleaner because it won’t get stuck up in a corner or get hung up by the main drain. Plus, it works in four pool surfaces: Gunite, Vinyl, Fiberglass, pebble, and Tiles. And it’s cheap given its efficient performance.

However, though it claims to work on vinyl surfaces, it actually requires a different set of tires. It also takes 4 to 6 hours before the Pool Cleaner can finish its job and you cannot program it to start or stop at a specific time. Still, it is the best suction pool cleaner on the market and the best suction pool cleaner for the money.


#2 Hayward PHS21CST Aquanaut

Hayward PHS21CST AquanautIf you want to come across with one of the best suction pool cleaners on the market, then check the Aquanaut 200. This features a V-Flex technology that provides maximum power at almost any flow and handles any type of debris minus the clogging part and multiple pre-programmed steering sequences ensure clean surfaces and walls. Add these up to the durable design and you get one pool cleaner that will let your pool experience complete clean.

The three easily interchangeable throats of the Aquanaut 200 improve suction performance at the lower flow and allow larger debris to pass. Meanwhile, its patented adjustable roller skirt ensures that it never loses suction on uneven surfaces or when encountering obstacles.

Aside from that, this pool cleaner is easy to set up and also easy to use. It is even ideal to use for speed pumps.

However, even this cleaner has drawbacks like the others. Some customers brought up the drawbacks of having this. One would be its durability that lasts only for two years. It also won’t climb walls of a fiberglass coated in-ground pool even with a lot of suction. And it hangs up on both of your pool drains


#3 BARACUDA G3 W03000 Advanced

BARACUDA G3 W03000 AdvancedThe Baracuda G3 is one powerful suction cleaner that works with low-speed pumps for maximum efficiency. It’s quiet as it works its job perfectly in secret. It eats up small and medium-sized debris and cleans your pool floor, even the pool steps, and walls. Featuring a wheel deflector that movement around tight corners and long-life hoses that eliminate scuffs on all pool surfaces, it is definitely one of the best compact pool cleaners you can ever encounter. It also highlights its FlowKeeper Valve that automatically regulates water flow to maintain peak cleaning performance even with lower horsepower pumps.

Aside from that, it has a 36 Fin Disc that increases adhesion to pool surface and prevents the cleaner from getting hung-up on lights, drains covers, fittings, and other pool features. You can also depend on this for a long time thanks to its durable long-life diaphragm that has a one moving part technology. With sturdy parts, you can surely get this going for years.

The Baracuda G3 has a one-year warranty and has a 2-year warranty on its long-lasting hose.

However, it doesn’t clean all parts of the pool. It also gets stuck randomly.


Best Pressure Side Pool Cleaner

ModelWeightWarrantyUser RatingPrice
Polaris Vac-Sweep 280
Polaris Vac-Sweep 280_100x
18 lbs.1 Year4.3/5$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon
Pentair LL505G Kreepy Krauly Legend
Pentair LL505G Kreepy Krauly Legend_100x
23 lbs.1 Year4.2/5$$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon
Pentair LL505PMG Kreepy Krauly
Pentair LL505PMG Kreepy Krauly_100x
21 lbs.1 Year4.0/5$$$$
Check Latest Price on Amazon

#1 Polaris Vac-Sweep 280

Polaris Vac-Sweep 280This pressure side pool cleaner features a three-wheel base and dual jets. It comes from the brand Polaris, which is recognized for producing innovative pool maintenance and cleaning equipment. They offer an array of pool vacuums including robotic and pressure pool cleaners.

The Vac-Sweep 280 is lightweight, making it possible to clean not only the walls and the base of your pool but also the stairs. The dual jets shoot dirt and debris up into the large filter bag in high speed. What’s more, this cleaner is compatible with all in-ground pool surfaces including Vinyl and Fiberglass. Connecting it to a suction line will be quick and the entire cleaning process will only take three hours or less depending on the size of your pool. The kit includes a 31-foot hose that can work for most pools. If it’s not enough, you can purchase an additional hose length.

One of the drawbacks of having this is that though it has “sweep” on its name, the rear sweep tail is not included. You have to purchase this accessory separately. Once installed, it can help clear up more debris from the corners and cracks in your pool. Another drawback would be its old design. Because of that, it has no additional internal turbines and has narrower intake valves compared to the latest designs.


#2 Pentair LL505G Kreepy Krauly Legend

Pentair LL505G Kreepy Krauly LegendSpend your $450 wisely by owning this famous Kreepy Krauly Legend. It has a front-wheel drive and has trodden tires that allow maximum traction on uneven surfaces to ensure overall pool coverage. It also features a large intake throat and high-capacity bag that handles large debris effortless and a four wheel design that prevents the Legend from tipping. You can forget all your troubles when you leave this cleaner to perform its duty. All thanks to its features, it can provide uninterrupted performance without the need for babysitting.

It utilizes water pressure to move and vacuum your entire pool in three hours or less. The throat is worth mentioning again because it doesn’t collect debris alone, it also contains it securely in the large bag that can be easily removed for cleaning whenever needed. The Legend also highlights a built-in backup valve that activates every 3.5 minutes to ensure total pool coverage and to avoid the cleaner from getting stuck up in steps and corners. It even comes with a tail hose scrubber that sweeps and scrubs the floor and walls behind it.

However, though advertised differently, it actually has a tendency to get hang-up at steps. And once stuck, it has no ability on its own to move away. The foam pad on the tail may also wear off after only a month.


#3 Pentair LL505PMG Kreepy Krauly

Pentair LL505PMG Kreepy KraulyPentair has done it again with the Kreepy Krauly Platinum. This is probably one of the most powerful suction-side pool cleaners on the market. It’s simple but very effective. It’s perfect for in-ground pools that are exposed to higher loads of leaves and debris. Even if your pool’s water is dark because of the dirt, the Platinum can still clear out all the dirt and provide you safe, clean swimming pool water.

It features dual thrust jets that provide optimum power for speed and suction in order to give your pool the cleansing it needs in just 1-3 hours. Given that it also has a front-wheel drive and has heavily trodden tires like the Legend, you can be assured that it will provide maximum traction on inclined surfaces for total floor and wall pool coverage.

However, it does have its drawbacks. What item wouldn’t have at least one, right? Well, first, the filter gets clogged easily. Second, the hose connections may be a bit loose. Third, adjusting its travel pattern can be tedious. Nonetheless, it’s still one of the best suction pool cleaners ever. It may not have the fanciest technology but it does its job well—cleaning.


What is a Robotic Pool Cleaner?

a robotic pool cleaner in actionA robotic pool cleaner is a high-end pool cleaner. It operates on its own with no need for human involvement. They work independently from your pool’s plumbing and filtration system. They have their own internal motor, pump, and electronic control unit. You don’t have to worry about its safety because the motor works at low voltage. Aside from that, they have a scanning feature that allows them to know the size and shape of your pool for faster and more effective cleaning.

Pros:

  • They save energy.
  • They clean faster.
  • They can eat up fine particles from your pool’s floor, steps, walls, and lines.
  • Some models feature remote controls for directed spot cleaning.
  • Some models have four wheels which are beneficial for uneven surfaces.

Cons:

  • They shouldn’t be left in the pool when inactive.
  • Their long power cord may be a tripping hazard
  • They are more expensive than pressure side and suction cleaners.

What is a Suction Pool Cleaner?

A suction pool cleaner connects with a hose to the skimmer box and uses the suction created by your existing pool pump to gather the dirt and debris which will then stay in your pool’s filter. Most automatic pool cleaners are actually suction type. There are two kinds of suction pool cleaners. The Inertia-driven suction cleaners clean with no specific pattern. Usually, they take longer to finish but they are cheaper than geared suction cleaners. Geared suction cleaners move in a fixed pattern and will clean faster than the former. They can easily get into tight corners and are suitable for smaller pools because of that.

Pros:

  • They are ideal if your existing pump and filters are already working great.
  • They remove debris.
  • Few moving parts that allow it to last long.
  • They also clean walls and floors.
  • You don’t need additional parts for this type.
  • They come with a long connection hose.
  • They are cheaper than pressure-side and robotic cleaners.

Cons:

  • You have to clean and backwash the filters often.
  • May not function properly if your pool’s plumbing and filtration system are small.
  • They use more electricity because they need the pool pump running in order to operate.
  • People with diatomaceous earth (DE) filters will use more DE than if they were not using a suction cleaner because it needs frequent filter cleaning.
  • It’s the slowest type of pool cleaner.

What is a Pressure Side Pool Cleaner?

A pressure side cleaner uses the pressure of your existing pump to push themselves around your pool. It’s actually the opposite of a suction cleaner only that they are more powerful than the suction cleaners. They work with an additional booster pump which means a separate hose connection in the pool wall is necessary.

Pros:

  • They have their own filter bags; thus, they do not add stress to your pool’s filter.
  • They work well for pools that gather large debris.
  • Together with the booster pump’s power, they can clean powerfully.
  • They have wheels for easy operation.
  • They clean faster than the suction cleaners.

Cons:

  • They do not scrub the surface the way professional pool cleaners do.
  • They do not collect fine particles and small debris.
  • They are ineffective in cleaning the walls of the pool.

They are electricity consumers because they need booster pumps to operate.

Which Type Do We Recommend?

We highly recommend that you watch the YouTube video below as it will also quickly teach you about the different types of pool cleaners:

Out of the three types, we recommend robotic cleaners. Allow me to give you the reasons why. First of all, they save energy. This is possible because of two things: it doesn’t require a running pool pump in order to work and the time in cleaning is reduced due to its efficient cleaning pattern. Second, they gather different kinds of dirt. Robotic cleaners can clean small particles like sand and silt. They can also clear large debris from your pool. Third, they don’t add stress to your existing pool filter because they have their own. Fourth, they have the most innovative features today. Fifth, they clean your entire pool—from tight corners to floor, walls, and steps. Sixth, it allows your existing pump and filter to live longer. Lastly, they are the fastest type of pool cleaners which means you can get a cleaner pool in less time than with the other two types. With all these benefits, I can confidently say that robotic cleaners are the best automatic pool cleaners on the market.


Things To Consider

There are a lot of factors to consider when buying a pool cleaner. Refer to the ones below to help you choose.

  1. Pool Type
  • Pools can be above ground or in-ground.
  • Other pool cleaners are only for in-ground, while other cleaners are great for both.
  1. Pool Surface
  • Pools have different types of surfaces.
  • They can be vinyl, concrete, fiberglass, tile, even pebble.
  • There are pool cleaners that can work only on certain kinds of surfaces.
  1. Size of the Pool
  • Choose a pool cleaner that can clean your entire pool.
  • If you have a small pool, don’t combine it with a very small cleaner because it won’t clean your pool fast.
  • Pools usually have sizes of 10 x 20, 15 x 30, or 20 x 40, the breadth is half of the length and has a 5.5 feet depth.
  • Select a pool cleaner that can clean your pool in less time than you can.
  • If it’s a robotic pool cleaner, then just check the time of cleaning it features.
  • One hour is enough but if you have a bigger pool, then don’t buy a cleaner that is too large for your pool. You will just waste energy and money.
  1. Suitability
  • Check what type of pool cleaner is right for your pool.
  • Suction type isn’t recommended if your pool always has large debris.
  • If you live in a place that doesn’t experience heavy winds often, then a suction pool would suffice.
  • If you have large debris in your pool, then get a robotic cleaner.
  • Suction cleaners are ideal if your pool usually collects fine particles like sand.
  • Pressure side cleaners are perfect if your pool usually collects large debris, leaves, or acorns.
  • Robotic cleaners independently devour bulky debris, small sticks, pebbles, dust, gravel, and algae.
  1. Type of Dirt
  • Determine what your pool collects—leaves or debris.
  • This will help you choose.
  • Robotic cleaners, with their new technology, works great, fast, and efficiently.
  1. Filtration
  • Some pool cleaners work independently from your filtration system.
  • Others have to be connected to your existing system.
  • Robotic cleaners have specialized filters and clean water all on their own.
  1. Warranty and Service
  • Make sure the item you’ll buy has a warranty.
  • It will be difficult for you to get it repaired without a warranty.
  • Most pool cleaners provide a 2-year warranty for manufacturing issues.
  • Don’t forget to contact the manufacturer for any concern.
  • Also, read reviews about their customer service before buying.
  1. Budget
  • This is one of the most important factors to consider before buying.
  • If you can afford expensive cleaners, then go ahead. Generally, expensive pool cleaners are way better and have more innovative features.
  • If you can invest in a 600-dollar pool cleaner for your in-ground pool, why not?
  • But be wise, too. If your pool doesn’t need a high-end pool cleaner, then buy one that suits the needs of your pool.
  • If you’re on a tight budget, then check out the best pool cleaner for the price range you can afford.

Conclusion

Owning a pool may sound fun, exciting, and stress-relieving especially if we think only about the good times we can have while swimming. More often than not, we forget the responsibility that comes with having a pool—cleaning.

Cleaning the pool can be tedious and exhausting especially on days with warm weather, which is also the perfect time to swim. As a pool owner, you have to know what’s best for your pool just like how a mother naturally knows what’s best for her children. You have to be aware of the different types and sizes of pool cleaners before you can choose what’s best for your pool.

If you want a pool with no dried leaves, stones, debris, or sand, then the best thing to do is to get going with your selection process. After all, the most effective way to clean your pool is with an effective automatic pool cleaner. There are so other factors to consider from the type of dirt down to your budget and with a plethora of choices, choosing can be more confusing than exciting. But with this guide, hopefully, I have made it easier for you to decide on what you should get.